Reader asks why Moray Council is cutting down so many trees across the region

NEARLY 40 trees at Cluny Hill have been cut down in the last few weeks.

And a Gazette reader who wishes to remain anonymous is calling for an explanation as to why Tree Preservation Orders (TPOs) have been revoked across the region, he claims, allowing destruction in areas including Forres and Findhorn.

The Elgin resident said: “Recently, 14 areas, including Grant Park, Findhorn, Elgin, Kingston, Garmouth, Seatown Buckie, Whitemire, Archietown, Fochabers, Keith, Findochty, Portnockie, Cullen, and Berryhillock have seen the swift removal of TPOs. Alarmingly, there has recently been significant felling on Cluny Hill. The revocation of TPOs seems contrary to the conservation initiatives and environmental carbon capture objectives set forth by government. Additionally, it takes decades for saplings to reach the size and maturity where they can capture carbon dioxide at a similar rate as older trees, making the preservation of mature trees even more crucial.”

The complainant believes “a lack of transparency is deeply concerning”.

He said: “I urge our local authorities to provide transparent explanations for these revocations and to reinstate the TPOs where necessary to ensure a greener, healthier, and more sustainable future for Moray.We must stand together to protect our natural heritage. Preserving our mature trees is essential, especially in the face of climate change. These trees are integral to our identity, providing beauty and solace to our lives. Trees support biodiversity, carbon sequestration, and mental wellbeing. Additionally, the tourism industry, a significant source of revenue for our region, relies heavily on the lush greenery and natural beauty that our trees and woodlands offer.”

A Moray Council spokesperson confirmed around 37 trees over an area of 1.14 hectares at Cluny Hill were recently felled, adding that there are plans for replanting.

She said: “Cluny Hill isn’t covered by a TPO, however, it falls within a conservation area. Under Section 172 of the 1997 Act, anyone proposing to cut down or carry out work on a tree in a conservation area is required to give the planning authority six weeks prior notice to provide an opportunity to consider whether a TPO should be made. On this occasion, we decided not to serve a TPO. The consideration of felling permission applications is the responsibility of Scottish Forestry and approval was issued in April. Cluny Hill has a woodland management plan in place that was agreed after extensive public consultation. The felling being carried out is in accordance with that.”

See https://www.forres-gazette.co.uk/news/cluny-hill-plan-to-enhance-the-forest-287185/

There were seven TPOs in Forres at Sanquhar, Croft Road, Drumduan House, Leanchoil Hospital, Woodside Drive, Dallas Dhu and Knockomie. As part of a review, the one at Croft Road was revoked on the basis that the amenity value of the woodland had been significantly deteriorated by historical tree works and no longer meets the TPO’s terms.

The local authority spokesperson added: “The revocation order was published for public consultation between April 18 and May 28. No representations were received. The Planning and Regulatory Services Committee subsequently confirmed the order on June 26 this year.”

She finished: “The only TPO in Findhorn remains in place.”