Home   News   Article

NICKY MARR: Shocking scenes from Afghanistan will raise many questions


By Nicky Marr

Easier access to your trusted, local news. Have a look at our brand new digital subscription packages!



Nicky Marr - coach/writer/broadcaster...Picture: Callum Mackay..
Nicky Marr - coach/writer/broadcaster...Picture: Callum Mackay..

The scenes that we are witnessing in Afghanistan are shocking. I’m writing this on Monday after a weekend of increasingly worrying news. The Taliban have taken control of Kabul, and I’ve just watched news footage of thousands of Afghans storming the airport, desperate to leave the country.

There is the sound of gunfire, and reports of people trying to cling to aircraft as they take off. The death toll is rising.

Should we have been in Afghanistan in the first place? History will judge that, but perhaps not. But the reaction to the withdrawal of western forces has been swift and deadly.

Where are the 300,000 Afghan government troops who were apparently well enough trained and equipped to resist the estimated 80,000 radical Islamists?

And how did the Taliban manage to regroup, attack, and overrun the presidential palace, all in such a short period of time?

Timsgarry Byre.
Timsgarry Byre.

The most pressing matter now, though, must be the welfare of the Afghan people, especially its women and girls. Already stories are reaching us of women being forcibly taken as wives, raped and enslaved.

Women in journalism, and media or culture roles, are changing their identities and destroying evidence of their education and achievements, to avoid death threats by the Taliban and those who believe women should not have equality. The future education of girls is under threat.

Unrest in central Asia seems far removed from the north of Scotland. Don’t we have issues closer to home to worry about? But there are always connections, and these links bring seemingly distant stories much closer to home.

Two years ago, I spent a few days at Timsgarry Byre on the west coast of Lewis, where I spent time with John and Lorna Norgrove. They rent out the Byre to raise funds for their charity, The Linda Norgrove Foundation.

Linda, their daughter, was working for an international development agency in Afghanistan in 2010 when she was captured by the Taliban. She was killed during a botched rescue attempt by US special forces. Linda was 36 years old.

Instead of turning inwards with grief, the Norgroves sought to carry on their daughter’s good work in the country she loved.

By the time we met, over £1.5million had been raised to support women and children in Afghanistan, funding education and healthcare.

They sponsored women through business, law, and economics degrees, and to become doctors, midwives, and healthcare workers.

John and Lorna were heartened by the impact of their foundation’s investments. But that was before this recent resurgence.

It feels unlikely that their work will be able to continue under a regime that curtails the rights of women, denies education for girls over the age of ten, and bans television, music, and culture.

We’ve watched newsreels of unrest in Afghanistan for decades and probably feel we’ve seen it all before. But we mustn’t forget the human suffering.

I’ll be watching our government’s response.

Surely, we can’t just turn our backs and walk away.

Click here to read more from Nicky Marr.



Do you want to respond to this article? If so, click here to submit your thoughts and they may be published in print.



This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies - Learn More